Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Will Lomas

Even if Locker has a good season, would the Titans be wise to draft a new QB?

16 posts in this topic

Jake Locker has a shaky future with the Titans that is directly related to having a healthy and successful 2013 with Tennessee. However, even if the Titans have a successful year and end up drafting between 16-22, should they go ahead and pull the trigger on a "back-up" quarterback.

 

This has nothing to do with Fitzpatrick (he will move to number three on the depth chart) but in a year where at least six quarterbacks have a chance to be legitamate first round values (Bridgewater, Boyd, Fales, Mariota, Hundley, Murray, Manziel, and McCarron) the Titans might be wise to find someone to groom if and when Locker hits his final contract year.

 

Worst case scenario, the Locker does great over the next two years and tries to charge the Titans a premium since they have another QB on the roster. If that happens then the Titans can use the same money to add other pieces and keep the rookie QB (whoever he is).

 

Best case Locker has two acceptable years, the Titans draft a capable, mobile QB and they have a Brett Favre-Aaron Rodgers type situation (but probably not with two hall of famers).

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If Locker has a good, promising season, I don't see any reason to draft a QB early. If there really are THAT many solid QBs coming out of the draft, one of the 7 would slip to the 3rd or later. We can grab one of them there if necessary. Don't think I'll be thinking QB come draft time if Jake looks good this season. If he looks good, he's our franchise QB. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't think Locker will have that good of a season, its possible he could but I'd probably take a bet that he won't, and if he doesn't I'm sure they will take a QB.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think Jake Locker will have a phenomenal season. I compare him to Christian Ponder. Both very young and a lot of talent. Just need weapons and learning how to use their talent.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Locker will mostly likely have a good season. It would make no sense to draft a new QB if he has a good season. There are good QB is almost every draft. Why waste a pick on one if Locker, a guy with great work ethic and physical abilities, is improving?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think we need to clear something up... Just even if you have a solidified starter at QB, doesn't mean you don't need to draft a backup. The Patriots grabbed Mallet the year after Brady won MVP. So, they probably will draft a QB, because a lot of teams draft QBs. It happens. 

 

That said, Jake Locker is going to have to play significantly better in order to earn a future starting role with the Titans. Yes, he tries hard, yes, he displays incredible effort on every play. But he is near the end of the "three year trial period" that is usually used to evaluate QBs. I think bias may have clouded the judgment of some of you Titan fans, because he has some serious mechanical issues, footwork being first and foremost among them. As of right now, he is not even close to good.

 

But, as I've said before, Jake went to UW, which is three miles down the road from where I go to school, and just about everyone I know (myself included) wants him to have a successful, prosperous NFL career.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think we need to clear something up... Just even if you have a solidified starter at QB, doesn't mean you don't need to draft a backup. The Patriots grabbed Mallet the year after Brady won MVP. So, they probably will draft a QB, because a lot of teams draft QBs. It happens.

That said, Jake Locker is going to have to play significantly better in order to earn a future starting role with the Titans. Yes, he tries hard, yes, he displays incredible effort on every play. But he is near the end of the "three year trial period" that is usually used to evaluate QBs. I think bias may have clouded the judgment of some of you Titan fans, because he has some serious mechanical issues, footwork being first and foremost among them. As of right now, he is not even close to good.

But, as I've said before, Jake went to UW, which is three miles down the road from where I go to school, and just about everyone I know (myself included) wants him to have a successful, prosperous NFL career.

Agreed. But as the post says, if he has a good season, there is no reason to not continue to push him as our starter. Now, if he doesn't have a good season and still needs a lot of work, then it's a different case.

And in Mallet's case, he was drafted to be groomed in that offense similar to Aaron Rodgers. Brady is nearing the end, while Locker is just beginning.

jhutch likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Agreed. But as the post says, if he has a good season, there is no reason to not continue to push him as our starter. Now, if he doesn't have a good season and still needs a lot of work, then it's a different case.

And in Mallet's case, he was drafted to be groomed in that offense similar to Aaron Rodgers. Brady is nearing the end, while Locker is just beginning.

There are talented QBs in every draft, but with such a stacked class this is probably the best opportunity to get a starting caliber QB with a pick from 16-22. The Titans don't have a big hole at OL, LB, S, DE, RB, TE, or DT. The biggest needs will probably be QB or CB and there are always quality CBs in rounds 2-3.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

There are talented QBs in every draft, but with such a stacked class this is probably the best opportunity to get a starting caliber QB with a pick from 16-22. The Titans don't have a big hole at OL, LB, S, DE, RB, TE, or DT. The biggest needs will probably be QB or CB and there are always quality CBs in rounds 2-3.

You really can't assume what our needs are going to be before training camp. For all we know, Stewart goes down with injury again and we move on without him. Or maybe the corners are fantastic and so is Jake, and then we have no need for a QB. Assuming what our needs are going to be before training camp is ridiculous, especially when our quarterback hasn't even started a whole season yet.
Joshua Huffman likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

And let's not assume too quickly that this 2014 QB class will remain stacked. Look how far Matt Barkley dropped after one season. Some of those quarterbacks that you're salivating over may drop pretty far.

 

If Locker is good, they're not wasting a 16-22 pick on QB.

Kenneth Goit likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Jake lockers ceiling is high. Very high. If he plays solid this year, not great but solid. There's no reason this team can't make a deep playoff run. The guy only has 11 starts. I don't get why this is said to be make or break for him.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Jake lockers ceiling is high. Very high. If he plays solid this year, not great but solid. There's no reason this team can't make a deep playoff run. The guy only has 11 starts. I don't get why this is said to be make or break for him.

Play your own Devil's advocate for a second ... what are the reasons that the Titans won't make a deep playoff run?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Play your own Devil's advocate for a second ... what are the reasons that the Titans won't make a deep playoff run?

 

Jake Locker. And possibly the defense adjusting to the new scheme. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Play your own Devil's advocate for a second ... what are the reasons that the Titans won't make a deep playoff run?
Lot of reasons . Too many question marks. Young inexperienced quarterback. The titans defense was historically bad last year, expecting a 180 is pushing it. Not to mention with Gregg Williams under a microscope it's possible he becomes a distraction for the defense. Not to mention, assuming you subscribe to the notion that Chris Johnson doesn't care anymore, that's more pressure on. Locker to carry the offense which is asking a lot for a 3rd year guy

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites